So for my first full weekend home in many months, I thought it would be great to gather some friends together on a cold, rainy Sunday and cook some yummy plov. To do this, I dug into one of my treasured recent acquisitions, The Art of Uzbek Cooking by Lynn Visson [Amazon].

A preview of what was to come.
The menu for this cold Sunday of deliciousness was a bit incongruous. The titles come from Visson’s book:
- Bukharan Beef Plov
- Fried Mushrooms
- Onion naan
- Uzbek-style Korean Carrot Salad
- Dark Chocolate & Bacon Cupcakes
Okay, that last one was clearly not Uzbek. My friend Miss B made them—recipe here—and man oh man were they delicious. Anyway, on with the recipes—including how I think they could be made better, supposed authenticity be damned.
I know I’m going to get nailed for the plov. It is one of the more personal recipe types out there—I’ve compared how people react to plov recipes with the way Italians gripe about pasta recipes (or Texans do barbeque). That being said, I’m going to post Visson’s recipe in a modified form, since I did not follow it exactly (for example, I didn’t just have sheep tail fat lying around). The results were still delicious.
Bukharan Beef Plov
(Guishti palov)
- 3/4 cup corn or cottonseed oil
- 3 large vidalia onions, peeled and finely chopped
- 1.5 pounds ribeye steaks, cut into 1-inch cubes (marbling and all)
- 6 carrots, peeled and cut at a quarter-inch bias
- 2.5 cups of basmati rice
- 3.5 cups boiling water
- Sea salt and freshly ground black pepper
- 2 teaspoons ground tumeric
- 2 teaspoons cumin seeds
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cumin
Heat the oil in a large, heavy dutch oven. I had an 8-quart stock pot, and it wasn’t wide enough to do this right. Sautée the onions for 3-4 minutes over medium heat until they turn soft and translucent. Add the beef and stir frequently, making sure it browns on all sides, for 10 minutes or so. Layer the carrots on top, but do not stir. Pour in the rice, evenly layering it on top of the carrots. Do not stir. Carefully pour the water over the rice, making sure the layers are undisturbed. The water should come about an inch over the rice. Add the seasonings and stir the rice only. Bring the entire mixture to a boil, then reduce the heat to medium-low, cover, and simmer for 40 minutes or until most of the water has evaporated.
After most of the water is gone, use the back of a wooden spoon to poke holes in the rice and allow the remaining water to simmer for another 20 minutes or so. Fluff up the rice with a fork, reduce the heat very low, and allow it to steam for another 20 minutes. Remove from the heat and let stand for 5 minutes or so, then scoop the rice into a serving bowl, with the meat and vegetables on top.

I served alongside the plov some “fried” mushrooms. I put the “fried” in quote marks because they didn’t work out exactly as I had hoped. I’ll post the recipe as I made it, and discuss how it could be made better.
Fried Mushrooms
(Kuizikorin kovurma)

- 2.5 pounds mushrooms
- Salt
- 3 medium vidalia onions, peeled and chopped
- 1/2 cup vegetable oil
- 1/2 cup strong beef broth
- 1/2 cup chopped fresh coriander (cilantro)
I took a shortcut and bought a bunch of the pre-sliced and washed mushrooms. Chopping two and a half pounds of mushrooms is just too much work for my lazy ass. Fill a really huge bowl with cold water, add about 4 teaspoons of sea salt, and soak the mushrooms for a few minutes. Drain them in a big collander.
Chop the onions finely. Heat the oil, add the mushrooms and onions, and simmer over medium-high heat, stirring frequently for about ten minutes. When the onions have softened and the mushrooms have given off a lot of their moisture, add a few pinches of salt and the beef broth. Bring to a boil, cover, and simmer for another ten minutes. Just before serving stir in the coriander.
Now, this resulted in delicious mushrooms, however I was disappointed in just how much liquid was leftover. There was a lot, and it was so runny I couldn’t properly call it a sauce (and I was not about to toss something like flour or cornstarch into it to make it tighten up). I would use less oil next time in a non-stick pan, sautée for a lot longer, maybe even ten minutes longer, and possibly halve the amount of beef broth I put in it. Again: these were delicious, just too watery.

To go along with all this deliciousness, I also made some onion naan. The recipe follows. My only caveat is that Visson does not use enough flour—after following her recipe, my dough was still really sticky and difficult to roll out. I ended up adding at least another half-cup of flour to the mixture, and I probably could have used more. I had to dust a lot of flour out to keep everything from sticking, and once I was done browning all the naans in the pan, I had to brush off a lot of excess and burnt flour.
Onion Flatbread
(Non)
- 6 tablespoons butter
- 2 medium white onions, very finely chopped
- 3/4 cup tepid water (110 degrees or so)
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 3 cups AP flour, unbleached
In a large heavy skillet, melt one tablespoon of the butter over medium heat and add the onions. Sautée until they are soft and translucent, but not brown (about 5 minutes or so). Remove them to a bowl to cool. In the same skillet, melt the rest of the butter and then pour it into a large heavy mixing bowl. Add the warm water and salt, then stir in the onions. Sprinkle in the flour, one half-cup at a time, and knead until the dough no longer sticks to your hands. Cover the bowl with a towel and set aside for at least 20 minutes.
Pull apart the dough and form about 10 to 12 balls, each about 2 inches in diameter. Lightly flour a board or countertop and roll out each ball into a flat circle about 8 inches in diameter. They will be very thin, so make sure you have enough flour to prevent sticking. I don’t own a rolling pin, so I used a can of soup, and it was perfectly adequate.
Heat an ungreased teflon pan over high heat and brown each dough circle for 3-4 minutes each side. There will be smoke from the extra flour, so make sure you’re in a well ventilated room and able to disconnect the inevitable fire alarm. Flip with a spatula. Cool the breads on a rack. I placed several on an ungreased cookie sheet in a 250-degree oven to continue crisping a bit more. You can serve these warm or room temperature—they’re delicious either way, and great for eating a lot of things besides plov!
Lastly, I made a spicy Korean carrot salad. It was expectedly delicious—most carrot salads are cloying and sweet, but this was was nice and tangy with a tiny bit of bite. I’ll be making it again in the future.

Korean Carrot Salad
(Uzbek style)
- 4 large carrots, peeled and julienned into 2-inch strips
- 2 scallions, trimmed and finely chopped (white and green—both are tasty)
- 1 clove of garlic, peeled and minced (don’t use a garlic press—this is better with noticeable garlic pieces)
- 2.5 tablespoons soy or shoya sauce
- 1 tablespoon white vinegar
- 1.5 tablespoons white sesame seeds
- 1.5 tablespoons dark toasted sesame oil
- 1.5 teaspoons sugar
- 1/2 teaspoon chili powder
- Pinch of cayenne pepper
Boil four cups of water and add the carrots. Cook for four minutes, the drain. Combine everything else in a medium bowl until the sugar is dissolved and everything is well blended. Pour over the carrots; serve at room temperature.
All of this food was quite delicious: my friends, who are not at all familiar with this kind of food, were excited to be eating it… including, to the point of ouchies from a tummy ache from eating too much. I was in the same boat, and after eating everything and watching some Wii Bowling I was ready for bed by 8 pm. But of course, I had one very un-Uzbek delicacy to consume:

(AHEM) I had four. I wasn’t alone—the chunks of bacon sound weird in the abstract, but are amazing in the flesh. So to speak. Eating like this has left me with a bit too much flesh, as you can see from the deliberately shrunk picture above. I guess I can’t eat like this all the time, but it was wonderful.
All photos taken with my iPhone, so apologies for the quality. I highly suggest buying Lynn Visson’s book, The Art of Uzbek Cooking.
{ 16 comments }
I think your fried mushrooms were watery because you soaked them in water — the mushrooms absorbed the water and then released it during cooking. To get a nice caramel color on fried mushrooms, they need to be very dry when they hit the pan. The beef stock is to “deglaze” the pan and get all the tasty caramelized mushroominess off the bottom of the pan and form the sauce.
Tictoc, I think you’re right — the recipe, though, called for soaking them in salt water. I thought that could have been to draw some water out of them, but it clearly didn’t work.
Maybe there was too much water and not enough salt. But, this is the first time I’ve ever seen a mushroom recipe that called for soaking mushrooms in water. Many recipes recommend against washing the mushrooms at all (clean them with a towel or soft brush). I guess, though, if you were using mushrooms picked in some forest in Uzbekistan, you would want to wash them and salt water seems like the best way. However, mushrooms bought in the US aren’t usually covered in dirt.
I know. It seemed strange to me as well, but I was trying to follow the recipe as written. I never wash mushrooms under ordinary circumstances.
Josh, my wife, who as you know is Kazakh, has reacted with horror to the idea of putting Korean carrot salad into plov. says it’s akin to putting ketchup in ice cream (actually, what she originally said was that it was like putting dried apricots into beshbarmak, but i didn’t quite get that reference so i asked about the ice cream). Then she said, “When did the Koreans come to central asia?” I think she is referring to them being relative late-comers, and so Korean salad can’t be an authentic addition to plov.
Uh-oh, we are having a Central Asian uprising now. Our Uzbek friend says the recipe isn’t Uzbek either. He says the carrots start out raw, then are fried in a really hot, smoking cooker using olive oil, then you add the meat and so forth.
Well, anyway, you get the drift.
Thanks for the recipe.
Best Steve
Josh, more shouting. Turns out that the meat goes first, and raw carrots last.
For the record, the carrot salad is served separately. I added thickly sliced raw carrot, per Visson’s recipe, after the meat and onions.
Carrots don’t go last. They come after meat and then only then rice.
Josh! the recipe says to put the rice on top of the carrots!
Josh, I’m going to have to look at Visson’s book. Thick carrots? That sounds like heresy. How would thick sliced Korean carrot salad make any sense? I think the guideline we need to try to follow for slicing the carrots is to keep them small enough to be used as a condiment on a hot dog.
If I had a bit of time between now and the beginning of May, I’d make a batch. I have a new technique I want to try.
No no no, “thick strips” of carrot for the plov; julienned carrots for the salad. I just had an inappropriate knife for julienning and I didn’t want to cut myself; that is why the carrot salad had such big pieces.
The “plov” you made looks like shavla – a moist and sticky version of plov with chunky vegetables.
Plov or “osh” as majority of Uzbeks refer to it is not made the same way in all areas of Uzbekistan. The way I make it is:
1. fry the meat whole, not chunky
2. add onions and fry
3. add julienned carrots, two spoons of tomato sauce, salt, dash of black pepper, squirt of chili sauce, cumin and water and bring to a boil for 10 min
4. add already soaked rice and water just barely above rice level and bring down heat
5. open 20 min later and carefully turn the rice over so that the rice on the top is buried and form it into a dome shape. Then with the handle of the spatula make holes into the rice to let steam out.
6. Cover and wait for guests to arrive
7. Serve on a big plate. Separate the meat on a cutting board and cut into bit size pieces and spread all over the rice with guests observing.
Optional ingredients: rice, chickpeas, quince (quartered), a whole bulb of garlic unpeeled and buried under the rice
Optional method: fry ingredients separately than rice. boil rice ten minutes. drain. put in a deep pan. pour some oil and a cup of water. cover pan. put it in an oven in 250 degrees for two hours. This will give you dry white rice. You serve the ingredients on a bed of rice.
Optional ingredients: rice! well, dehhh!
I meant to say raisins.
Josh: Most of the time in Uzbekistan, I saw the salad and osh carrots cut the same size. Because I’m lazy with prep, I often buy the pre-julienned bags of carrots at the supermarket.
Cooking the meat as one large piece is more traditional, but I’ve done it both ways (and I’ve done it with pork roast as well!). That’s actually related to the idea I want to try. Slow cooking is part of what I think makes oshxona osh so good. I’m wondering if braising roast and putting it in a slow cooker with spices and some of the veggies then dumping the results into a pot to finish with the rice might yield good results.
I forgot to mention that I also like to add a couple heads of garlic during the rice phase. You get some nice garlic paste out of them at the end.
Mmmm…I’m going to have to try making some of those dishes. Those carrots look/sound yummy! So do the cupcakes! Thanks for sharing the recipes!
Now THAT’S a lively discussion!
Oh well, being blessed (or not, your choice) with no further knowledge on Uzbekistan, I’ll simply try out the recipe some time