Site menu:

Recent Comments

RSS News Wire

RSS neweurasia

Links:

Tags

Academia Afghanistan air strikes aitmatov Andijon Announcements Armenia Azerbaijan Belarus blogosphere Bolashak Books Borat Business Cartoons Caspian Caucasus Central Asia central asia china east turkestan Central Asian Union China CIS Corruption Counternarcotics CSTO Culture Democracy Diplomacy East Turkestan Economics Education Elections Energy Environment EU Europe Events Food Crisis Football Fundamentals Gas Geography Georgia Germany great game History Human Rights Humanities India Internet Iran Islam Islamism Japan Journalism Karimov Kaz Kazakhstan Korea Kyrgyzstan Language Law Maps Media Military Affairs Mongolia Movies Music nationalism NATO NGO North Caucasus North Turkestan obituary Oil Organizations OSCE Pakistan Peace Corps Pictures Policy Propagandists Recipes Religion Reviews Roundup Russia Saakashvili SCO Site Announcements Skylarkings Society South Asia Sports Tajikistan Tamerlane Tatarstan TEFL The Great Game The War Travel Turkestan Turkey Turkmenbashi Turkmenistan Ukraine Untagged US USSR Uzbek Music Uzbekistan Video Wikipedia Women

Meta

Site search




blog advertising





Global Voices Online - The world is talking. Are you listening?


Subscribe in Bloglines

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Subscribe in Rojo

Add to Google






Dishonest Broker

Georgia claims that three Russian helicopters attacked villages in the Kodori Gorge, the only part of Abkhazia controlled by Tbilisi. A UN observer mission is investigating the incident.

Georgian officials claimed on Monday that Mi-24 attack helicopters from Russia had flown sorties over the border during the previous night and had struck government buildings and houses in the towns of Azhara, Chkhalta and Gentsvishi.

Only experienced and well-trained pilots could have made some of the shots, they said, as the approach to the targets required flying in darkness with night-vision goggles through a narrow and often fog-bound gorge.

There was evidence suggesting that artillery or ground-to-ground rockets might have been fired at the villages as well. Investigators were still examining the shrapnel, however, and the question of whether ground-to-ground ordnance had also been used was not clear, a military officer involved in the United Nations’ investigation said.

Regardless of whether or not Russia is to blame for the incident, this situation underlines just how inappropriate it is for Russia to be involved in peacekeeping operations for the conflicts between Georgia and its separatist regions. I have heard more than a few Russians give voice to their bleeding hearts and proclaim their government merely desires to protect the poor people of Abkhazia and South Ossetia from the predations of the wicked Georgians. It is so painfully obvious that it is a shame to have to repeat that their assertion is bunk. Russia is as much a party to these conflicts as are Georgia and the separatist governments. And it has taken steps to ensure that it is even more heavily involved by, for example, extending citizenship to the populations of both regions. It has not shown the slightest inclination toward being an honest broker.

Georgia has proven itself quite capable of irresponsibly stirring up conflict; it is no innocent itself. But the continued presence of Russian troops only gives Saakashvili’s government reason to occasionally raise tensions. Georgia’s government wants Russian troops gone, and so long as they are there and supporting the separatist governments, Georgia can credibly claim to be resisting a much larger aggressor. And about the only way it has been able to get the West to pay attention is to send bullets and shrapnel flying.

Especially for Europe, Georgia is strategically important to the West given its location and its participation in strategies to export Central Asian and Caspian energy supplies bypassing Russia. Its separatist conflicts absolutely should get more international attention than they do. Solutions are far from easy to come up with, and Russia should not just leave without some third party taking its place. Who would be appropriate though? Mongolian troops? KAZBAT?

UPDATE: Or, hey, maybe getting Russian troops out won’t help at all. They could always just attack from Russian territory.

Photo from Flickr user and part-time resident of Georgia drivercore. Visit his photostream for more great pictures of Georgia.

Stumble it! |

Comments

Comment from Laurence
Time: 3/14/2007, 2:17 pm

Nathan, Interesting news item, but I don’t think America or the EU want to go to war over Georgia, given what’s happening in Iraq or Afghanistan. This incident may have literally been a “shot across the bow” by the Russians. MESSAGE: If you are not willing to fight, stop stirring up trouble–because Russia is willing to fight over Georgia…and maybe over Kosovo, too…

Just speculation, of course since there is no evidence.

Comment from Nathan
Time: 3/14/2007, 2:27 pm

But Georgia is willing to fight, and Russia understands that. Georgia recently took Kodori by force from the militia that had been running it. I have my doubts that Russia really wants to fight. The segment of the Georgian army that is better trained and equipped than the Russian military keeps growing.

Granted, we don’t want to fight over it, and I’m not suggesting we should. But we should pressure Russia to quit pretending to be neutral and to leave. Shit or get off the pot, as it were. If Russia wants to annex the territory, it needs to do so. If it recognizes them as independent, it needs to do so. If it agrees that it is under the sovereignty of Georgia, it needs to leave. The whole situation is absurd. The peacekeepers there need to be from a more neutral country.

And, by the way, there is evidence. It’s just not been presented by anyone but Georgia yet.

|